“ First time enjoying this pizza. It was a takeout for 6. We ordered through the phone and went to pick up. It was ready within the time they said. We ordered a square pepperoni pizza and a round cheese pizza. They were both delicious. Also ordered some chicken wings. Good also. ”

“ Im a frequent visitor to Papa Doughs, and I can definitely see what the hype is about! I ordered the Mushroom Delight Pizza, and it did not disappoint. The crust had that perfect balance of crispiness and chew, the sauce was flavorful but not overpowering, and the mushrooms were fresh and generously spread across the pie. The wings were another highlightcrispy on the outside, juicy inside, and packed with flavor. Whether youre a fan of classic sauces or something a little different, theyve got you covered. But the real surprise? The deepfried peanut butter and jelly. I wasnt sure what to expect, but it was ridiculously goodcrispy, warm, and just the right amount of sweetness to round out the meal. If youre in West Haven and craving quality pizza with some unique menu items, Papa Doughs is definitely worth a visit! ”

“ I really like the concept! Its good to see a new twist on pizza. We got the 4 small pizzas in a box plus traditional and boneless buffalo wings! I cant wait to try some other pizzas and wings. I would recommend this restaurant to anyone in the area! The customer service was top notch and the food was great. The place has plenty of seating space and the freshly renovated space gives modern vibes. Parking is also a plus. ”

“ I tried them for the first time last night and OMG sooooooo good. I got the party box of pizza which is good if u have a big family. You can choose four different kinds. The vodka sauce and chicken pizza a must have , I also got the dough bites and wow so good like little pillows so good. Not greasy either. When u eat pizza you want good sauce and good crust and they definitely have it. Then we got the deep fried calzone cant go without getting a deep fried calzone lol it was amazing. Then lastly I got the steak and cheese egg rolls let me tell u , they were so good and the dipping sauce chefs kiss will definitely be going again. Next time Ill be trying the deep fried peanut butter and jelly and gotta get the fried Oreos. So get up and go get ya self some amazing food. You wont be disappointed. ”

“ Dont come here if you dont like being treated extremely well, or getting service with a smile. The owner saved me 30 on my order just because. Then I get home and the food is freaking addictive. I had a sausage and pepper herodelicious and my wife had a chicken Ceasar panino. It was so good she let me taste it Overall the place is great if youre local or if you want an authentic New Haven style apizza. This will be on my list of regulars. ”

“ Just the best. Went here after a bodybuilding competition. Boy, did it hit the spot. I wanted pizza with toppings that had flavor and mass to it. I was able to get just that with the shareable pies. Pizza was cooked to perfection with a crust that was crunchy but soft at the same time. It was savory and so delicious. The wings were superb. Great dry rub. Cooked perfectly. The fries and Alfredo sauce were mouth watering. I have ZERO complaints about the food. I was so full and happy when we were done. The workers were welcoming and so cool. I am so bummed that I live no where near this place or itd be dangerous!!!! Thank you to Papa Doughs for making my entire day!!!! ”

“ A great spot for family pizza night! Papa Doughs has plenty of pizza options to choose from and even offers a party pack, which includes the choice of four off their menu. Of course, that is what I chose since there were a few unique ones I wanted to try. I ordered the Philly cheesesteak, Big Papa vodka sauce, chicken cutlet, bacon, Return of the Mac think Big Mac, and the Carmela my personal favorite roasted red pepper, garlic, mozzarella, truffle balsamic. Delicious pizza wish there was more sauce on some, as it was used as a drizzle on top rather than the base, but that is my personal preference. They also have heroes, wings, fries, calzones, and an amazing dessert menu. I suggest the churro fried dough sticks, which are served with a frosting dipping sauce. Service was great, and there is plenty of seating inside, and a few arcadeclaw machines. ”

“ Loving the creative menu over at Papa Doughs! Though they offer New Haven style apizza, theyve also made an effort to branch out and offer signature square pizzas, as well as different topping choices. Its nice to have a unique option in New Haven county! Even their appetizers and desserts are on the same level of creativity. Everything we had was fantastic! Plenty of seating in the dining room, and the food arrived to our table quickly. ”